Just another WordPress.com site

A “gender activist,” Rita Banerji, believes despite the activity of thousands of women’s organizations in India,[i]

The women’s movement today in India unfortunately is like an ingrown toenail. It is going in the wrong direction. For example, there are women arguing that sati [when a widow joins her husband on his burning funeral pyre] is not murder but cultural and religious way of women committing suicide, so we shouldn’t defame it; or that we should continue to allow Muslim men to legally have four wives. It is hurting itself. So mothers-in-law murder daughters-in-law; women strangle their own baby girls. When a group of women at a pub last year were molested and beaten up for “violating Indian tradition” the NCW (the National Commission on Women), the highest office protecting women’s rights, said the women had asked for it because they were drinking and inappropriately dressed.

The Feminist movement believed that a woman’s body and being is her personal domain. Freedom within and freedom without. But in India the women’s movement sees women just as suppressed citizens that have to be given rights. Do you see the difference? The only feminist movement we had has now died out completely. The women who started it were getting death threats and they just shut everything down. I wrote about it online.[ii]


Ms. Banerji maintains that what she refers to as gender-based genocide in India is the most massive in history and the violence is increasing. Young married women and baby girls are killed every few minutes, without evoking anywhere near the same response as killing a cow. The highest female death rates are in the middle and upper educated classes. In response, she sponsors an online petition called “The 50 Million Missing Campaign” that demands that laws against female infanticide, dowry, dowry murders, and honor killings be implemented.[iii] In an article titled “Why Kali Won’t Rage: A Critique of Indian Feminism,” Banerji charges that despite ongoing assaults on females, women don’t share and disapprove of “disapproval of western feminist anger” and emphasis on the harmful effects of patriarchy. Indians are raised to accept a gender hierarchy where women are expected to be “domestic,” meaning compliant, despite a countervailing tradition of female goddesses as powerful shakti forces. As in the battered women syndrome, women self-blame and try to please the abuser so that the murderers in bride burning are often female in-laws. The consequences of lack of feminist protest is women hold only 11% of political offices, it’s a low 112 out of 134 countries ranked on a Global Gender Gap report, has one of the lowest female literacy rates in the world and one-third of the child brides.


Comments on: "A Critique of Indian Feminism by Rita Banerji" (1)

  1. In medicine it is a mistake to treat the symptoms and not the disease itself.

    Sati and that as women strangle their own baby girls are only symptoms.

    Only an act of making a society’s wealth. It is the Old Norse law that gives wife’s family tries duty if the marriage terminated. Bride’s family is very interested in a lasting marriage, and they are looking for why the bride is an accomplished woman and the man is busy and hard-working. And a country full of busy and hard-working men and talented wives, will soon be rich.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: